On October 17, The Wall Street Journal published an article titled, “A Princeton Ph.D. Applied to 2,300 Jobs. He Still Can’t Get One.” Thirty-year-old Jack Weis ventured through all fifty states. He drastically lowered his initial lofty ambitions to entry-level food-preparation jobs. He graduated summa cum laude from Rice University, and his research was cited by the Nobel committee when it awarded the Nobel Prize in physics in 2024. Clearly, his credentials provide quite the compelling argument for an employer, and yet he simply could not find employment. This begs the question: are Jack’s struggles indicative of broader trends in the labor market?
The answer is no, despite his poor luck. Jack’s story paints a bleak picture of the labor market. For previous generations, college acted as a surefire guarantee of employment. This should especially be the case for an applicant with Jack’s resume.
Affordability, however, presents a much more tangible threat to post college livelihood.
Millennials and Gen X-ers crave any opportunity to flaunt this fact, suggesting that college graduates should simply figure it out. In a sense, their sentiment is not entirely incorrect. Empirical evidence blatantly contradicts the labor pessimism echoed through Jack’s story, revealing that college graduates are securing employment with as much ease as ever. Affordability, however, presents a much more tangible threat to post college livelihood.
According to the Federal Reserve, the unemployment rate among college graduates aged twenty-five to thirty-four was 2.6% in September. The national unemployment rate for this age range was 4.3%. A college education clearly still holds supreme value in the eyes of employers, and this boost has remained consistent for decades. Opponents may argue that the unemployment rate for college graduates rises to 7.6% when looking at 20-24-year-olds. While this number is still lower than the national average for this range, the unemployment rate for college graduates will always be higher than anticipated. College graduates intentionally and commonly leave jobs to pursue opportunities that will eventually reap higher rewards, making them technically and temporarily unemployed. In addition to low unemployment figures, yearly pre-tax earnings of college graduates rested around $100,000 in 2024. These, and countless other statistics, highlight that the outlook in the labor market is not bleak whatsoever for college graduates. So, where does this negative sentiment come from?
This number, compiled with the aforementioned statistics, implies that Jack and his unlucky peers do not represent systemic shortcomings of the labor market.
Media sources like The Wall Street Journal tend to reinforce college graduates’ pessimism about the labor market through stories like Jack’s. In July, The New York Times published an essay titled, “Gen Z Fell Out of Love With Work. I Don’t Blame Them,” which argues that Gen Z-ers are pessimistic about their job prospects, and that they are right to feel that way. Both articles emphasize that there exists an underlying inevitability of unemployment waiting for young college graduates in the workforce but cite only anecdotal evidence in support of this claim. In Jack’s case, the national unemployment rate for chemical engineers rests around 2%. This number, compiled with the aforementioned statistics, implies that Jack and his unlucky peers do not represent systemic shortcomings of the labor market. News outlets thrive on inspiring feelings of crisis in their consumers, and the labor market fear-mongering embodies this tactic.
While the job market might not be as daunting as many believe, the affordability crisis vindicates some of these fears. The exorbitant cost of crucial purchases provides an example. In 2025, the National Association of Realtors reported that the first-time home buyer share fell to a historic low of 21%, while the median age of first-time buyers rose to 40 years old. The cost of necessities, such as gas, food, and healthcare, has skyrocketed as well. These metrics prove that simply living poses a considerable challenge in the United States — a challenge more significant than previous generations have faced. The lack of financial stability for recent college graduates may oftentimes exacerbate the hurdle of affording basic goods.
Thus, the attention given to the college-graduate employment crisis in media and popular discourse appears baseless and trivial.
Although the same cannot be said for affordability, penetrating the job market does not present as much of a difficulty as many graduates think. Thus, the attention given to the college-graduate employment crisis in media and popular discourse appears baseless and trivial. Generally, college graduates enjoy considerable financial support or await significantly higher earnings than those without a degree. Concern for those without the means to afford college or access the employment benefits of a degree remains largely insufficient. The top 1% of U.S. households hold just over 30% of the nation’s wealth, while the bottom 50% hold about 2%. Those at the bottom of the economic ladder have historically low capabilities for upward mobility, while Elon Musk was recently crowned the world’s first trillionaire. Although it might garner less engagement, news outlets should allocate their attention to substantiated, pressing issues rather than pandering to their audience. The country’s colossal wealth inequality probably deserves more attention than Jack Weis’s postgraduate struggles.
Jordan Falk ‘28 studies in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at falk.j@wustl.edu.