An October Prediction Before the Midterms: The Swan Song of the Originalists?

Last month, when asked about his future, Associate Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito dismissed speculation that he would retire, noting that he intends to stay on the bench through the November midterms and the current court term, if not longer. While the decision of his colleague, Justice Clarence Thomas, is far less certain, the question of his retirement has also likely been considered for Thomas, as the Court’s longest-serving active justice. With the Supreme Court being such a philosophically polarized institution, the eventual departure and replacement of the two justices represents a critical inflection point in our nation’s future, a decision that will fundamentally shape our country’s law and policy in the decades to come.  

For the Republican Party, the looming exit of Justices Thomas and Alito represents an impending chasm, the eventual loss of two titans who together have shaped Supreme Court rulings through conservative influence for over two decades. From 1937 to 2025, rulings analysis (conducted by a group that included WashU Chancellor Andrew Martin) has indicated the only justice more ideologically conservative in their rulings than the two has been former Chief Justice William Rehnquist. In the most recent term, Alito and Thomas voted together on 97% of resolved opionated cases and 100% of closely divided rulings, becoming one of the most aligned justice pairings in Supreme Court history. They have been the Court’s strongest proponents of originalism, a form of Constitutional interpretation utilized to varying degrees by the rest of the Court’s conservative bloc and critical in landmark rulings like the overturning of Roe v. Wade. Critically, at a time when President Trump has criticized the court for ruling against his decisions, the two elder statesmen have been the President’s most reliable voices on the bench, voting in favor of his preferences in close to 89% of rulings dating back the last decade. On a court with three justices appointed by Trump himself, Alito and Thomas still stand out as the preeminent voices in favor of the President, the two foremost opinions which have formed the bedrock of the current Court’s conservative supermajority.

For those who have long hoped for the [Alito and Thomas] to step down, the 2026 midterms represent a pivotal junction.

If Republicans manage to maintain control of the Senate this November, the duo are likely to stay on the bench through the end of the 2028 session before this question arises again, upon which Thomas would become the longest-serving justice in Supreme Court history. If the Democrats were to retake the Senate, they are left with two options to avoid a liberal seat replacement: leave the bench immediately following the midterms, or remain, hoping for Republican control in 2028. Should either of the two step down, it is very possible that the current Senate could replace them with a conservative justice before the new Congress takes office. After all, there are around 60 days between election day and the start of a new Congressional session, and Republicans were famously able to nominate and confirm Amy Coney Barrett just 38 days after the death of Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Given the optics of this path as well as public comments made by the two, it is likely that they would opt for the latter option, an avenue that gives the Democratic Party its best chance at chipping away at the Court’s conservative orientation.  

While Neil Gorsuch and Amy Coney Barrett are the Court’s two controversial election-year Trump appointees, Alito and Thomas have long drawn the most scorn from Democratic voices. In a party dominated by anti-Trump messaging, the two have been heavily criticized for many of their decisions, with their tenures marked by calls for investigation and alleged conflicts of interest. For those who have long hoped for the two to step down, the 2026 midterms represent a pivotal junction. A Democrat-controlled Senate would allow the denial of any potential conservative replacement until the next election cycle, upon which the pair would be well into their 80s. Any potential future leftward shift in the court begins with the displacement of Alito and Thomas with liberal justices, making this year’s midterms critical in the Democratic Party’s wishlist.

In a campaign season dominated by foreign relations and affordability, it is important to remember the ramifications our votes have on our nation’s judicial outlook.

Elections have consequences. In a campaign season dominated by foreign relations and affordability, it is important to remember the ramifications our votes have on our nation’s judicial outlook. For the Republican Party, the impending midterms represent an opportunity to maintain the status quo, to allow their two foundational mainstays to remain on the bench and make conservative-leaning decisions before graciously bowing out to younger voices. For the Democrats, this cycle is a critical checkpoint in their campaign efforts, their first swing since the disastrous 2024 election and a chance to address the Supreme Court’s conservative turn. For over twenty years, Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas have been pivotal in shaping our nation’s law at the highest level, and their impending departure will leave two great voids, both in their ideological party and on the court itself. How those gaps are filled will depend on the American electorate.  

Steven Jeon ’28 studies in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at jeon.steven@wustl.edu.